Split Strategies in PA’s Higher Ed Overhaul

By  - 
The Shapiro-Davis Administration has been working to give Pennsylvanians the second chances they deserve – signing comprehensive probation reform legislation into law, securing historic funding for indigent defense, and more.

Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro’s vision to revamp the state’s higher education system includes bolstering struggling public colleges, enhancing affordability, and addressing workforce development needs. Lawmakers from both parties are now introducing legislation to implement this vision, reflecting bipartisan acknowledgment of the need for change.

Both sides agree on the necessity of a performance-based funding model but differ on the specifics of implementation. Pennsylvania’s complex higher education landscape, with numerous public institutions facing enrollment declines, necessitates careful deliberation to translate broad concepts into practical solutions.

Democrats propose a State Board of Higher Education and substantial need-based aid to cap student expenses at $1,000 per semester for those at or below the median income level. This board would develop a strategic plan and advise on issues like tuition and program cuts, while policy enactment would remain with the general assembly.

Republicans argue against granting too much authority to such a board, preferring a task force focused on information gathering and decentralized decision-making by institutions and advocating for targeted scholarships to attract out-of-state students and fill workforce gaps. 

Experts caution that effective reform will require substantial investment and a coordinated approach to align with state goals. While there’s enthusiasm for bipartisan engagement, the urgency of the issue underscores the need for timely action to avoid exacerbating existing challenges in Pennsylvania’s higher education landscape.

“I think what you’re seeing in the Senate is a willingness in trying to address the fact that we’re 49th in the nation when it comes to higher ed…[and] we’re going to work together… to find common ground,” Shapiro said during a Tuesday press conference.

Though challenges remain, including funding allocation and balancing state-level control with institutional autonomy, there’s optimism among lawmakers, educators, and experts for progress.